Supremely well said. A true pro laptop without compromises. I have one I bought in 2014 - i7 and I am not every buying the new design till it is a reliable pro machine.
Totally agree, @marcoarment. Recently sold the LG monitor, prepping the Touch Bar MBP to be sold. I greatly prefer my Thunderbolt Display with the 2015 15” MBP.
100% agree and that’s really well written. I have tried both Retina MacBook and new Pros (sans TouchBar) and I keep coming back to my 2015 MBP. It feels like a professional computer.
I’m not alone! Though not as eloquent or productive with my mbp as the others, I too ditched a new MacBook Pro touchbar stellar grey almost bland HP-like thing for the tank that is the 2012 15” MBP Retina.
exactly right. One additional detail: only the 2014 (which I own) and 2015 are brand-free on the hinge, below the screen. All the others are branded “MacBook Pro”, feeling in your face… in a Samsung way.
I love this. I’ve got a brand new iMac that I adore and a 2013 15-inch MacBook Pro that needs a new battery. With the keyboard stuff with the TB MBP, I’m almost tempted to get another one. (From 2015 like you)
hell of an endorsement. im in the market for one for sure. wondering if a refurbished model from apple would be better (apple care wise) than a “lightly used” one off ebayz
I agree with Marco. Mine has been a beast used every day all day for 4 years. But yeah my 2006 17” I still have (used by my daughter as a backup) and besides batteries that sort of exploded a few times it still works great!
I'd still be using my old matte screen 17" if the logic board hadn't died one night. But the replacement (retina 15") is as good or better in every way, and I don't miss the old one much.
Following suit from ATP, I got a 2015 from Swappa. 40 battery cycles, 512 GB SSD, and 2 years left of Apple care for 1600! I Highly recommend giving it a look!
I’m in the minority, but I prefer the new one. Hated having unused ports (HDMI, SD) - much rather have 4 that can adapt. I now bring two charges when traveling, USB-C (MacBook/Switch) and lightning (iPhone). Also planning to get an egpu when they’re better supported this Spring.
I have one of these with 16GB/512SSD. 2 complaints: 1) fan runs too often when the CPU pegs, and 2) it's just too heavy...I'd prefer a 13" with same specs and less weight
Fully agree here, and makes me a bit sad to see design principles go haywire with the tbMBP.
Worth mentioning imo that the 2012 rMBP started the non-upgradable components trend for the MBP line (e.g. RAM, SSD, battery).
I bought a 2015 13 inch when the new ones came out. I felt a bit of a FOMO while getting it as my "reasonable" choice. I've never regretted my decision since.
The loaded mid-2015 13” MBP is the best of 6 new MBPs I’ve owned since 2004. No interest in the Touchbar. Paired with my 12.9 iPad Pro with Duet it’s a killer road warrior setup.
Same here. Best Mac laptop I've ever owned. I guess if there had been one with 4 USB ports and no Touch Bar, MAYBE I would have picked that... But in the end, when I read the horror stories with the keyboards and the dongle life, I'm more than happy with my 2015 !
I’ve got a 2015 MBP and a 2013 MBA and end up using the MBP far more often. What I miss about the MBA is Apple’s willingness to give a low-end model *much* better battery life than the high-end model in the name of ultraportability - wouldn’t see that now.
[see also the unused empty space in the current day non-touchbar MBP’s chassis]
the ridiculous excellence of iOS devices today makes me wish the Mac were actually becoming more and like a truck - it has more freedom to go in that direction than it used to
I was able to snag a maxed out Retina, 15-inch, Mid 2015 MacBook Pro when Apple was still selling them. It’s my daily driver and my all-time favorite machine.
I worked at the Genius Bar until this summer. Before I left I used my discount to buy a new laptop and I went with a maxed-out 15” 2015 over the Touchbar one and I am so thankful I did.
I still have my 5 year old top-model MacBook Pro and there is no way I can part with it.. The only thing which lets it down is the battery after all this time. It still has more horsepower than many new laptops on the market!
I’m really tempted but the pricing was horrible when I looked locally here. The retina MacBook has the battery attached to the keyboard or some madness which blew the pricing to hell and back :(
“It’s designed for us, rather than asking us to adapt ourselves to it.” Forcing us to adapt is unfortunately the state of all Apple products right now. There is a clear lack of vision company wide and we’re all stuck being beta testers while they try to figure out what works.
Totally agree. For many reasons, especially the gap between trackpad and space bar to rest my fingers while using the trackpad. I like the glow of all the little Apple logos on tech tables in a dark auditorium during theatre production rehearsals. Be sad when that’s gone.
I love my 2015 MacBook Pro. I will be really sad the day I need to get a new Mac laptop. For a video editor on the road, it’s damn near perfect.
I’d love to have an Nvidia GPU for the CUDA core benefit, but other than that it’s absolutely perfect.
If only my 2013 Macbook was a little faster and the screen wasn't delaminated and I could charge it w/ a USB-C charger i'd be set. Everyone's disdain for these new ones is keeping me from upgrading
I got a new one on eBay with Apple Care for almost the full 3 years for $2k not that long ago. I think they went up a little after the touch bar models were revealed.
Despite completely disagreeing with the premise and conclusion of this piece, I enjoy your love for the Mac.
Great photography, well reasoned arguments, and a nice homage to a great machine.
You’re wrong about the new machines, but you’re right about these machines. Thanks.
I run the (2017) 13” touchbar Mac, not the 15”... so maybe it’s the bigger ones. Dunno, but I love this 13” Mac.
Small as an 11” Air (my all-time favorite), but as fast as the 15”. I sometimes walk back to my desk in the evening because I panic and think I forgot to pack it.
Do you ever plug anything into it? Is it your primary machine? I suspect the fruit companies insularity may be shielding it from how everyday workers use their Macs.
My daily shooter is my iPhone, with my Fuji’s as travel cameras. Since I offload those cards in bulk, a usb-c reader is faster and not an inconvenience for me.
Understood. I personally prefer not having to remember to keep the external card reader but we can have our own preferences. On another pt, iPhone X RAW perf is great so I can see using it more and syncing it via iCloud.
iPhone has been a very capable camera for a while. Have a lot of 24” prints on my walls from past iPhones.
And with the latest models, I find myself using my other cameras less and less.
I’ve heavily used both the 7 plus and the 8 plus. It’s a great system. The X is even better.
It’s not a traditional system, but once you get the feel of it, you can make some incredible photographs with it.
I tend to have camera vibration when I hit the button on the phone. On a DSLR it's relatively easier to hold it steady. I haven't tried iPhone rigs or sth like that so my experience is from hand holding only
For majority of cases, I'm sure it's great. Sometimes I highlights meter and underexpose to recover the shadows in LR. So better dynamic range in RAW is very much welcome :)
Same, but I also use it on the go quite a bit. I'm holding off on upgrading a '14 MBP at work and a '09 MB at home, _entirely_ because of the keyboard. Tried new one at the store, low travel makes me hit keys harder. Serious RSI concern. :(
What monitors are you using @capttaco ? I’ve got a 2016 MBP 13”. On the road it’s fine (travel a lot) but in home office really want screen real estate
I still regret “upgrading” and want to go back every time I borrow my old MBPr from the kids. It was a 2013 model, but is doesn’t feel slower than the brand new one I have.
The new TB3 only models went too far with their vision of "purity" or "simplicity". I have to admit that the older MBP's, with their large variety/quantity of ports LOOKS less modern than the current ones - but are WAY more practical.
Reading this on a late 2013 15" rMBP (500gb SSD, 2.3GHz i7, 16Gb DDR3, NVIDIA GeForce GT 750M) - purchased in 2014 and still going beautifully. Still happy and no regrets.
Interesting. You might be the outlier there. At the time, many people (myself included) complained about the loss of MagSafe 1, which stayed plugged in far better than 2.
I needed to “upgrade” from my late 2012 rMBP recently and... well... performance of the 2017 rMBP does not match the increase in specs... considering the price this is really shit
I’m quite happy with the new MBP 13”, except the keyboard reliability issue. Thinner and lighter are way more important than other things in my checklist, as long as it’s reasonably powerful.
Run bootcamp. Install MSI Afterburner. Enable GPU frequency overlay. Play overwatch. Within 5-10 minutes it’ll throttle from from 800mhz to 300mhz. FPS will cut in more than half. ~60 to 23.
Logic:
We’ve added a touch bar. Videographers and Photographers will love it.
Also @Apple logic:
We’ve removed the SD slot because not many of our users are photographers and videographers.
I almost wanted to tweet the same thing today. Still remember my 2007 17" MBP which I absolutely loved. That laptop in a unibody frame would be to die for. (With updated ports)
Bought a Late 2016 recently to replace my Early 2013.
New screen is nice, keyboard is fine, but battery is a massacre. For the same tasks, the duration on battery is less than half of the old one with a fresh batt. I really don't get what happened with this gen...
Agreed! I'm still kicking myself for selling my 2012 15" rMBP to get this "supposedly better" 2017 MBP with its touch bar. Yes, its fast, thin, quiet and light... but man... even after almost 5 months, I still hate the keyboard.
I never realized the new ones have it on the right. That is awful. I have headphones like Marco mentioned with the cord off the left side. I would literally have to wrap my headphone cord around the back of the laptop so it doesn’t get in the way.
I see so many new MacBook Pros driving 4K displays at 30 Hz because people didn’t know any better and got a cheap USB-C HDMI dongle. The (2012–2015) MBP is the new MD101LL/A.
Apple user since 1985. Former Lisa & NeXT owner. Ex Apple staff. The best laptop I’ve ever laid hands on was the original Chromebook Pixel. Years too early, but it made all other laptops look like greasy pizza boxes. My only complaint on this MBP was I got too small a HD.
I'll never again buy a 2016+ MBP unless major design changes happen but that won't stop others from buying. Don't forget Apple had record sales of current gen MBPs.
Totally agree my mid 2013 MBP has 5 dead pixels and starting to make some fan noise. Dreading an “upgrade” to the new one. Thinking very hard about a 2015 one w/regular keyboard.
Miss my 13” MacBook Pro, I feel my 12” MacBook is a trip to the Genius Bar waiting to happen with all the keyboard problems. I’m selling it before that happens.
Love my 13” Pro from 2014. The skepticism about the new laptops (and the price tag) have made me hesitate about upgrading- hoping they’ll either fix the keyboard concerns and go all in or bail on the Touch Bar.
I’m looking to upgrade from a 2013 MBA. I do a lot of photography, so I figured I’d need the discrete GPU. You don’t feel like anything’s lacking using the integrated?
Largely agree, but:
- in 5 years I went through for 4 them (various internal component failures),
- lots to dislike about the OS,
- I perceive the chime (or rather the lack of an option to turn it off) as a middle finger to the user; interesting to see you celebrate it.
That's why I bought a maxed out 2015 model the next day after 2016 touchbar mutant was presented. And I'm seriously thinking to buy a spare one just in case.
Totally agree with this! Bought a fully upgraded touchbar Mac a few months ago, but I am still using my late 2013 regularly not feeling it being inferior at all, even though I was planning for it to be replaced entirely.
Seems Jobs' externally projected reality distortion field collapsed onto Apple with his death. Apple, no longer able to see Pro users' reality, went on a minimal design spree that failed to address Pro users' needs. Apple shows faint signs awareness but the field is still there!
I'm milking mine from 2012 because I haven't found anything I like better. It may get more RAM and a new battery and remain my primary machine for a few more years.
I’m still using my 2013 15” MBP and really loving it. Looked at the new MBPs released last year and thought ‘nope’, glad I stuck with old faithful here.
great blog, but Im one of the few (or maybe the apple greater mass) that owns and adores the 2016 Touch Bar MBP. Sure it is not perfect but I would not go back to the 2015 model. Admittedly my definition of "pro" will be very different to you as more akin to a power user than I
Totally agree. I have one for work and it’s just perfect. Does everything I need extremely well. Some odd choices have been made since this laptop unfortunately.
If you get one that doesn't develop the screen delamination fault, that Apple may try very hard to get you to pay for, and seems to involve several weeks without the machine to get it fixed....
well said! in an era where the new shiny toy is somehow sought after I have had a horrible time convincing folks these are an overall win over a base 15/touchbar/mush keyboard. 👏👏👏👏
I bought this laptop in 2012... top spec... it kept crashing and was very disappointed. On eBay 4 weeks later. Now have an awesome Alienware which would kick the arse if ANY apple product! Still very happy with my 256gb iPhone 7 though!
My 2015 still heats up to egg-frying temps too quickly. Other than that, # of ports, SSD, screen all ++. The pre-Lenovo Thinkpads had incredible build quality though. Some lasted 10+ years.
Thanks for writing this, it started my descent into a rabbit hole of research that made me realize a 2015 MbPro is my future video editing laptop vs a Windows laptop. The used prices on this model are too sweet to ignore.
I honestly miss my 17” 2011 MacBook Pro. Thanks for reminding me that it’s gone. I’m just a little sour that Express Card didn’t make it as a tech standard.
Recently own the latest MacBook Pro. New to the Mac family. Yes, I had to adapt. But it is still a delight to use. And I'm ever hopeful of Apples future.
I have the mid 2012 model but it’s getting sluggish especially while editing video. I’ll have no choice but to upgrade. Also the speaker blew on this model, and I have a staingate screen so I won’t say the greatest ever. My 2010 model was flawless and upgradable.
So much truth here. I had a 2017 touchbar MBP fail on me after 3 mo's. Switched back to my late 2014 retina MBP and she doesn't miss a beat. That felt like the peak of Apple quality.
Agree though I would say the MagSafe adapter style on the previous MacBook Pro was actually better, it didn’t break away if your leg bumped it accidentally.
What about the sound and screen quality?
The speakers of the 2016+ are really surprisingly good. Does the 2015 hold up against them?
Did you notice a big difference between the displays?
The ending was really powerful. I have saved bottles and cans for a new MacBookPro to replace my mid-2009 one and truth be told I am getting a souped up mid-2015 one because it is the only one worth getting. The TouchBookPro is Not My Apple.
Couldn't agree more. I was apprehensive at first with a non-user-replaceable battery. But I grew to love this thing and loath the day I must replace it. Hope someone at @Apple will bring a true successor to the 2015 Retina.
The original MBPr design is great, I like smaller so I still use a 13" retina. I bought another 13 used but battery serviced one for my fiancee. I now have the touchbar at work, but still vastly prefer the OG retina design, mostly for ports & keyboard.
You're absolutely right @marcoarment. Whenever I play with the new ones, the keys feel wrong, no magsafe scares me, and dammit I need an escape key (vim). I have a 2015 dGPU personal one and an iGPU early 2016 for work. I'm very happy. I'll use them until they croak.
Maybe the best MacBooks ever made, got a 2015 one.
Prefer form, size and weight of my MacBookAir though. It's just lacking RAM and resolution.
The current models are a no buy unfortunately.
I'd say the Panasonic Toughbook CF-5x series is the best laptop ever, at least for heavy-duty (200K+ miles/year) road warriors like me. It comes installed with Windows, for those who must suffer the low quality thereof, but makes a dandy Linux box, if you can get away with that.
I have a 2017 non-tbMBP and the fact that I've been shopping around for a hub annoys me and makes me regret ever buying one. I love it until I want to use it at my desk.
It's my favorite. It's an amazing work horse. I have yet to see another machine that lets me run 4+ virtual environments simultaneously, w/ 50+ tabs open, alongside countless other software, while being portable and nice to look at. I really hope they stay true to their vision.
Couldn't agree more about the keyboard. I can't seem to get used to the new arrow keys and the overall shorter travel. One wishes Apple stayed with the "Inverted T" layout.
I've got a Late '15 13" MacBook Pro and Early '16 MacBook. MacBook is the best laptop computer as a whole. True portability (size/weight). Exquisite display. Excellent battery life (10-12 hrs). Solid keyboard. No extraneous ports. Simple.